Boyle boot (above), or up top, as delivered by the same company's Boomer style (below)? Personally I think a snug ankle lends itself to dressing up a boot, while a roomier one has a more casual vibe. So maybe it depends on when, where & how you're planning on wearing your narrow calf boots.
If we can't have it all, do we choose that great fit up down, down low, or call it a toss-up and look at features such as hardware and other details, quality of materials & price as the tiebreakers?
If anyone feels like piping up, I'd love your input! If you have to pick, what's your priority?